Center On Executive Compensation
News

Center Submits Comments to SEC on Re-Proposed Pay for Performance Rules

Published on: March 5, 2022

Authors: Chatrane Birbal

Topics: Executive Pay Legislation and Regulation

The Center submitted comments to the SEC this week in response to the reopening of the comment period for the 2015 Dodd-Frank Pay for Performance rule. In our comments, we reiterated the Center’s concerns about several aspects of the 2015 proposal and urged the Commission against adopting inflexible, prescriptive, one-size fits all performance metrics in a mandated table.

Building on our initial comments in 2015, the Center urged the Commission to consider several concerns: 

  • The mandated pay for performance table required by the rule is unworkable and should be scrapped. Instead, the SEC should adopt a principles-based rule that allows companies to effectively explain the relationship between pay and performance.
      
  • Requiring the disclosure of prescriptive financial performance metrics (i.e., pre-tax net income and net income) is ineffective because there is no single metric or group of metrics that accurately reflects value creation for all companies.
      
  • The 2015 Proposal’s definition of “compensation actually paid” does not accurately reflect that term. The Center believes the Commission should fundamentally rethink that definition, particularly as it relates to stock options and pension values. 

In addition, we noted that given the prevalence of pay for performance disclosure and the extensive resources available to investors to determine performance, it is not clear whether investors need or want the standardized, tabular disclosure contained in the 2015 Proposal, or how such information would enhance investors’ understanding about the link between corporate pay and performance.

Ultimately, the Center cautioned the Commission that if a rule like the 2015 Proposal is finalized, it would create more confusion than clarity for investors.

Chatrane Birbal

Vice President, Government Relations, HR Policy Association

Detailed Bio

Contact Chatrane Birbal LinkedIn

MORE NEWS STORIES

Center On Executive Compensation Warns SEC Against Over-Regulating 10b5-1 Plans
Executive Pay Legislation and Regulation

Center On Executive Compensation Warns SEC Against Over-Regulating 10b5-1 Plans

April 08, 2022 | News
Incorporating Risk into Executive Compensation
Compensation Committee and Board

Incorporating Risk into Executive Compensation

March 26, 2022 | News
Center's Comments to SEC: Re-Proposed Pay for Performance Rule Is Prescriptive and Misleading
Executive Pay Legislation and Regulation

Center's Comments to SEC: Re-Proposed Pay for Performance Rule Is Prescriptive and Misleading

March 11, 2022 | News

Continue reading this content with the Center On Executive Compensation Membership package