HR Policy Association
News

Association Supports Motion to Rehear Case Protecting ERISA Preemption

Published on: May 14, 2021

Authors: Daniel W. Chasen

Topics: ERISA Preemption and State Laws

HR Policy Association joined an amicus brief urging the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to rehear a case in which the court decided the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) does not preempt a Seattle ordinance imposing health care requirements on certain employers.

Under the Seattle ordinance, hotels with 100 or more rooms and ancillary hotel businesses must provide full-time workers with health benefits equal to a gold-level policy on the Washington state health exchange or pay the equivalent directly to the employee.

While local in nature, the ruling has national implications.  “The repercussions of the Court permitting a single locality to exercise this type of power over ERISA-covered plans reach much further and threaten to alter the regulatory landscape materially and irreparably for employee benefit plans—not solely health plans—across the United States, to the detriment of employers, plans, participants, and beneficiaries.” 

The court’s decision clashes with the Supreme Court’s interpretation of the expansive preemption provision in ERISA, and conflicts with several subsequent Circuit Court rulings on the matter, our brief backing the ERISA Industry Committee’s (ERIC) petition to rehear the case argues. 

The brief “is a clear sign that employers across multiple industries support a strong federal standard governing employer-sponsored health care, over disparate state and local mandates,” ERIC President and CEO Annette Guarisco Fildes said in a statement. 

Daniel W. Chasen

Vice President, Workplace Policy, HR Policy Association

Detailed Bio

Contact Daniel W. Chasen LinkedIn

MORE NEWS STORIES

Biden Calls on Congress to Lower Drug Prices for Everyone
ERISA Preemption and State Laws

Biden Calls on Congress to Lower Drug Prices for Everyone

April 30, 2021 | News
Circuit Court Backs Seattle Health Care Mandate on Employers
ERISA Preemption and State Laws

Circuit Court Backs Seattle Health Care Mandate on Employers

April 09, 2021 | News
Health Care: Beyond Opioids, Are Bipartisan Reforms Possible?
ERISA Preemption and State Laws

Health Care: Beyond Opioids, Are Bipartisan Reforms Possible?

August 29, 2018 | News