HR Policy Association
News

For Second Time in Two Weeks, Federal Court Strikes Down NLRB Scrutiny of Workplace Harmony Rules

Published on:

Topics:

Even before a Republican majority on the NLRB has been installed, federal courts are beginning to bring balance back to the law, as the 5th Circuit struck down a controversial 2016 Board decision that a handbook violated the National Labor Relations Act by asking employees to maintain a "positive work environment."  Specifically, the court found the Board's decision to be "unreasonable," stating: "The reasonable T-Mobile employee would understand the rule to express a universally accepted guide for conduct in a responsible workplace."  Among other handbook items in question that the court approved were prohibitions against:
  • "[A]rguing or fighting;"
  • "Failing to treat others with respect;"
  • "Failing to demonstrate appropriate teamwork;" and
  • "Access to electronic information by non-approved individuals."
The decision comes just two weeks after the 8th Circuit overturned a Board decision that a leaflet suggesting a link between a restaurant's sick leave policies and customer safety was legally protected, with eight appeals court judges agreeing that the NLRB's decision "fundamentally misconstrued" the law.

MORE NEWS STORIES

ELG Annual Meeting Unpacks Federal Workplace Policy and More
Employee Relations

ELG Annual Meeting Unpacks Federal Workplace Policy and More

June 27, 2025 | News
DEI Remains Top Issue For Trump Administration
Employee Relations

DEI Remains Top Issue For Trump Administration

June 27, 2025 | News
White House and Hill Priorities Impact Workplace Agenda
Employee Relations

White House and Hill Priorities Impact Workplace Agenda

June 27, 2025 | News